
Technological breakthroughs
Using apatite to treat wastewater from phosphate fertiliser plants
Nearly 800 million litres of phosphate-rich wastewater spilled into Tampa Bay in the United States in 2021. Most of this phosphate was captured within hours by apatite grains already present in the bay’s sediments, and it did not return to the water for at least three years.

Florida has mined phosphate ore for more than 130 years. Since the 1940s, most of the ore has been processed on site into fertiliser using the wet process, in which sulphuric acid is used to dissolve the ore and produce phosphoric acid. This process generates large amounts of phosphogypsum waste, which is piled into huge stacks.
One of these is the Piney Point stack near Tampa Bay, which operated from 1966 until the late 1990s. When it closed, lined ponds were added to store process water, which is acidic and contains phosphate, nitrogen, heavy metals and radionuclides from the ore.
An emergency release of 800 million litres
In March 2021, a pond at Piney Point began leaking. Concerned that the retaining walls might fail, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection ordered the stack’s owner to take emergency action. Over 10 days, about 800 million litres of mixed wastewater, rainwater and seawater were released through Port Manatee into Tampa Bay to relieve pressure on the walls.
The wastewater was rich in nitrogen in the form of ammonium and has been linked to algal blooms in the bay. Phosphate can also fuel algal blooms and deplete oxygen in water. However, the fate of the large amount of phosphate released into the bay had remained unclear.
Phosphate stayed near the release point
A team at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in the United States sampled the bay floor sediments almost every month from 2021 to May 2024. Samples were taken from the top 2 cm of sediment at 12 sites along the eastern shore of Tampa Bay, including three control sites far from the wastewater plume. The results were published in the journal Communications Sustainability.
In the bay water, dissolved phosphate concentrations were always below the detection limit of 0.02 ppm. According to data compiled by the Tampa Bay Estuary Program, phosphorus levels in the water returned to background levels within a few days of the release.
The sediments, by contrast, contained unusually high levels of phosphorus near the release point and to the south, along the path of the wastewater plume. At the control sites and at sites 3–10 km to the northeast, average phosphorus levels were below 350 ppm. At a site less than 20 m from the release point, the figure rose to about 2,000 ppm. The highest was at a site 4 km to the south, with an average of 3,300 ppm.
Notably, the southern sites contained many apatite grains. Apatite is a natural phosphate mineral, and these grains had been worn by water from Florida’s well-known “Bone Valley” ore region. At two southern sites, apatite made up 11–15.5% of the sediment grains, compared with less than 1% at most other sites.
Apatite acts as a “seed” for phosphate
To understand the mechanism, the team mixed simulated wastewater with simulated seawater at a range of ratios and added different materials.
Without any solids, phosphate barely disappeared from the water over several weeks, even though the water was supersaturated. According to the authors, magnesium ions, which are abundant in seawater, hinder phosphate from precipitating on its own. In contrast, with apatite present, 28–77% of the phosphate was removed from the water within just 30 minutes. After 3–16 days, this rose to 54–96%. Calcite removed only about 40% after 1–16 days. Quartz sand and natural sediments from the bay also took up phosphate, but more slowly than pure apatite.
According to the researchers, phosphate first sticks to the surface of apatite grains and then gradually crystallises into new calcium phosphate minerals. The existing apatite grains act as “seeds” for phosphate to crystallise on.
An order-of-magnitude estimate shows that the amount of phosphorus in the released wastewater and the amount accumulated in a sediment layer about 1 cm thick within 5 km of the release point were both roughly a hundred tonnes. According to the team, the sediments may have retained almost all of the phosphorus from the wastewater.
Using apatite to treat wastewater
The authors say the results point to a way of treating wastewater at phosphate fertiliser plants. Finely ground apatite or apatite mining tailings could be added to ponds holding calcium- and phosphate-rich wastewater, helping the phosphate precipitate and lowering phosphorus levels in the water. According to the team, this approach could be applied at phosphate fertiliser facilities around the world.
The study also has some limitations. The team sampled only the top 1–2 cm of sediment, and the bay water was no longer analysed for phosphorus after 2022. Phosphorus levels in duplicate samples from the same site differed by 37% on average, showing that the sediments are uneven. The link between phosphorus levels and apatite content was clear only at the northern sites. The experiments used simulated water rather than real wastewater. The study also did not consider nitrogen, which has been directly linked to the algal blooms that followed the spill.
References
• Major J. D., Feng T., Pasek M. A. Rapid removal of mining waste-contributed phosphate from estuarine waters by pre-existing apatite in north Manatee County, Florida. Communications Sustainability, 2026, 1, 61. DOI 10.1038/s44458-026-00060-8
Compiled by Bao Hien
Pyrolysis, ozone and bacteria in tyre recycling
Date 17/11/2026Sodium-ion batteries enter commercialisation
Date 16/11/2026

